Skip to content
Energy

FERC Rejects a $19.9m Bill for a Coal Plant That Made No Power

TransAlta wanted California and the Southwest to help pay for keeping Centralia available under a federal emergency order. Regulators told it to bill the Northwest only.

By
· Updated 3 min read
inLinkedIn𝕏Post
Centralia Power Plant, September 2020
Centralia Power Plant, September 2020 · Steven Baltakatei Sandoval · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on 1 October 2026 rejected TransAlta's plan to recover $19.9 million it spent keeping the 730 MW coal-fired Centralia plant in Washington available under a US Department of Energy emergency order. The unit generated no electricity at all in the first seven months of this year, according to Energy Information Administration power production data.

FERC's objection was geographic rather than philosophical. TransAlta had proposed recovering part of the cost from the California Independent System Operator and the Southwest Power Pool. The commission noted that the Department of Energy justified its order by citing the North American Electric Reliability Corporation's 2025-2026 Winter Reliability Assessment, which found the Northwest assessment area, covering Montana, Oregon, Washington and parts of northern California and northern Idaho, faced elevated risk during periods of extreme weather. Any revised filing, FERC said, should recover costs only from load-serving entities inside that area.

On whether a plant producing nothing can bill anyone at all, the commission sided with TransAlta.

We find that the Emergency Orders' statements that Centralia 'shall not be considered a capacity resource' do not preclude the commission from approving compensation for the costs that TransAlta incurred to keep Centralia operational.

— Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, order issued 1 October 2026, eLibrary accession 20261001-3020

Who turned up to object

The opposition was broad for a cost-recovery docket. It included the Bonneville Power Administration, the Southwest Power Pool, the California ISO, Snohomish County Public Utility District and other public power utilities, the state of Washington and its Utilities and Transportation Commission. Calgary-based TransAlta had planned to retire the unit at the end of 2025 until the Department of Energy's first 90-day order in mid-December blocked it, and told FERC it expected to spend a further $23 million on repairs to keep it available.

The order lands three weeks after the department's use of section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act took its first serious hit in court. On 11 September 2026 a unanimous three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit vacated the first such order, which had kept Consumers Energy's J.H. Campbell plant in West Olive, Michigan running past a May 2025 retirement date already approved by state regulators and the MISO grid operator. Judge Cornelia Pillard, writing for the panel, called section 202(c) a narrow, last-resort backstop and found no emergency within the meaning of the statute. Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel had challenged the order, extended five times before the ruling.

The department has not retreated. Since the Campbell decision it has renewed 202(c) orders covering units owned by CenterPoint Energy, Northern Indiana Public Service Company, Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association, PacifiCorp and others, and issued a further 90-day order to TransAlta on 11 September. Since May 2025 it has used the provision to stop units at seven power plants retiring, all but one coal-fired.

The judgment worth stating plainly is that cost allocation, not legality, is now the binding constraint on this policy. Vacating one order took sixteen months of litigation. FERC can decline to spread the bill in a single order, and did. If emergency-order costs must sit with load-serving entities inside one NERC assessment area, the utilities and state commissions in that area have every reason to contest each renewal, and the per-customer arithmetic becomes visible in a way it never is when costs are socialised across three markets. That matters beyond Washington state, because the reliability assessments the department leans on are being stretched by data-centre load, as Parallax Nexus reported in August when PJM asked FERC to curtail new data centres first.

The total cost of the programme is not known, and no federal agency publishes a running figure. Consumers Energy's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission put the cost of running Campbell past its retirement date at more than $248 million by June 2026, about $642,000 a day. The Sierra Club, which litigated against the orders and is not a neutral party, estimates roughly $583 million across all units held open under 202(c). TransAlta's own plan is to convert Centralia to natural gas by the second half of 2028, a roughly $600 million project yielding 700 MW under a 16-year supply agreement with Puget Sound Energy.

What happens next?

  • TransAlta may refile a narrowed cost-recovery plan limited to load-serving entities in the Northwest assessment area.
  • The Department of Energy's current 90-day order for Centralia, issued 11 September 2026, expires in December and would need renewing.
  • Separate legal challenges to the remaining 202(c) orders continue, and the DC Circuit's Campbell reasoning will be tested against records where utilities supported the order.
  • NERC's 2026-2027 Winter Reliability Assessment will show whether the Northwest is still rated at elevated risk, the finding the Centralia order rests on.

Sources & references

  1. 01FERC rejects TransAlta 202(c) cost-recovery plan for Centralia unit — Utility Divenews2 October 2026, by Ethan Howland. Reports the order of 1 October 2026 and quotes it directly; links the FERC eLibrary filing under accession number 20261001-3020.
  2. 02Order on TransAlta Centralia cost recovery, accession 20261001-3020 — Federal Energy Regulatory CommissionprimaryThe commission order of 1 October 2026 rejecting the cost-recovery plan and setting out the assessment-area limit.
  3. 03Federal Power Act Section 202(c) TransAlta Order No. 202-25-11 — US Department of EnergyprimaryThe first 90-day emergency order for Centralia, issued mid-December 2025, which prevented the planned end-2025 retirement.
  4. 04Federal Appeals Court Vacates First DOE Order Forcing Operation of J.H. Campbell Coal Plant — Michigan Department of Attorney Generalprimary11 September 2026 statement confirming the DC Circuit ruling and that the department had extended the order five times.
  5. 05Court Rules Against Trump Order to Keep Michigan Coal-Fired Plant Operating — POWER MagazinenewsSource for Judge Cornelia Pillard's wording and for the Consumers Energy SEC filing figure of more than $248 million by June 2026, about $642,000 a day.
  6. 06Electric Power Monthly and Form EIA-923 power production data — US Energy Information AdministrationdataGeneration data showing the Centralia unit produced no electricity in 2026 through July.
Published 3 October 2026 · Updated 3 October 2026 · Report a correction · How we use AI
inLinkedIn𝕏Post

More from Energy

View all
Energy

France May Forgo 65bn Euros of EDF Dividends for New Reactors

France's state audit office warned on 16 November 2026 that EDF may not be able to fund six new EPR2 reactors without further state money, and set out a scenario in which the government gives up all cash dividends, worth about 65 billion euros between 2026 and 2040.

3 min read
Energy

IEA Sees a 1.7m Barrel Oil Surplus as Gulf Exports Return

The International Energy Agency's November Oil Market Report, published on 13 November 2026, forecasts fourth-quarter supply of about 105 million barrels a day against demand roughly 1.7 million lower, reversing the deficit it projected a month ago. Diesel stays tight, and the gap between the IEA's demand estimate and OPEC's is now wider than most years' total growth.

3 min read
Energy

IEA Lifts Its Renewables Forecast to 4,800GW on Energy Security

The International Energy Agency's annual renewables report, published on 6 November 2026, forecasts almost 4,800GW of new renewable capacity between 2026 and 2031 and says renewables will supply almost 45 per cent of global electricity by 2031, up from 33 per cent in 2025.

4 min read
Energy

Turkey Puts $500bn Behind a 281GW Power System by 2040

Energy Minister Alparslan Bayraktar set out a $500bn investment plan taking Turkey from 123GW of installed capacity to 281GW by 2040, with $116bn of it going into transmission and distribution rather than generation. It lands four days before Turkey hosts COP31 in Antalya.

3 min read